Criminal litigation is about more than defending against accusations; it’s about upholding justice and ensuring that every individual receives a fair trial.
Criminal Litigation
Criminal litigation in Pakistan encompasses the legal processes involved in prosecuting and defending individuals accused of criminal activities. Governed by a complex framework of laws, primarily the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), 1860, and the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), 1898, criminal litigation addresses offenses ranging from minor misdemeanors to serious felonies, including theft, assault, murder, terrorism, and corruption.
Legal Framework
The criminal justice system in Pakistan is grounded in several key statutes:
Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), 1860: This is the primary penal law in Pakistan, defining offenses and prescribing punishments. The PPC covers a wide range of criminal acts, including offenses against the state, human body, property, and public tranquility.
Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), 1898: The CrPC outlines the procedural aspects of criminal litigation, including investigation, trial, appeals, and execution of sentences. It also defines the roles and powers of law enforcement agencies, courts, and the prosecution.
Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA), 1997: This law deals specifically with terrorism-related offenses, providing for special Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATCs) that expedite trials and impose severe penalties.
National Accountability Ordinance (NAO), 1999: This law governs the prosecution of corruption cases, handled by the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) through special Accountability Courts.
Juvenile Justice System Act (JJSA), 2018: This act provides for a separate legal framework for dealing with juvenile offenders, emphasizing rehabilitation and ensuring that minors are treated differently from adult offenders.
Stages of Criminal Litigation
Investigation
Criminal litigation begins with the investigation phase. When a cognizable offense
(one where police can arrest without a warrant) is reported, the police lodge a
First Information Report (FIR). This is a formal complaint that triggers the
investigation process. The police then gather evidence, interview witnesses, and may
detain suspects. The investigation concludes with the submission of a challan
(charge sheet) to the relevant court.
Arrest and Bail
During the investigation, suspects may be arrested if there is sufficient evidence
linking them to the crime. After arrest, the accused is presented before a
magistrate within 24 hours. The magistrate may grant remand (custody for further
investigation) or judicial remand (sending the accused to jail). The accused can
also apply for bail, which may be granted depending on the nature of the offense and
the circumstances of the case. Bail applications are decided by magistrates,
sessions courts, or high courts.
Trial Process
Once the challan is submitted, the trial begins. The trial process involves several
stages:
Charge Framing: The court
formally frames charges against the accused, who is
asked to plead guilty or not guilty.
Prosecution's Case: The
prosecution presents its case by submitting evidence,
examining witnesses, and cross-examining the defense’s witnesses. The prosecution
bears the burden of proof, needing to establish the accused's guilt beyond a
reasonable doubt.
Defense's Case: The
defense presents its case, challenging the prosecution's
evidence, presenting its own evidence, and calling witnesses to testify on behalf of
the accused.
Final Arguments: Both the
prosecution and defense present their final arguments,
summarizing the case and highlighting key points of evidence and law.
Judgment
After hearing the arguments, the court delivers its judgment. If the accused is
found not guilty, they are acquitted. If found guilty, the court convicts the
accused and proceeds to sentencing.
Sentencing
In cases of conviction, the court imposes a sentence based on the severity of the
crime. Sentences may include fines, imprisonment, or, in cases of serious offenses
like murder or terrorism, the death penalty.
Appeals and Post-Trial Procedures
Both the prosecution and the defense have the right to appeal the judgment or sentence. Appeals can be made to higher courts, including the Sessions Court, High Court, and ultimately the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The appellate courts review the case for legal errors, re-examine evidence, and may either uphold, overturn, or modify the lower court's decision.
Special Courts and Tribunals
Pakistan's criminal justice system includes several specialized courts and tribunals:
Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATCs):
Handle terrorism-related cases under the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997, ensuring swift trials
and stringent penalties.
Accountability Courts: Deal
with corruption cases under the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999.
Military Courts: Established
to try cases involving terrorism and national security, particularly when civilian
courts are deemed inadequate.
Juvenile Courts: Handle cases
involving juvenile offenders under the Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018, focusing on
rehabilitation rather than punishment.
Challenges in Criminal Litigation
Criminal litigation in Pakistan faces several challenges, including:
Delays in Justice:
Prolonged trials and delays in the judicial process often result in
injustice, with cases taking years to resolve.
Corruption: Corruption
within law enforcement and the judiciary can undermine the fairness of criminal
litigation.
Inadequate Legal
Representation: Many accused individuals lack access to competent legal
representation, particularly in rural areas.
Overcrowded Prisons: The
slow pace of trials and difficulty in obtaining bail contribute to overcrowded prisons,
exacerbating human rights concerns.
Our Services
Taxation Litigation
Litigation Services
Family Cases
Criminal Litigation
Corporate Registration
Constitutional Law Practice
Service Matters
Our Practice Areas
Free Consultation